Welcome folks! 👋

This edition of The Product-Led Geek will take 8 minutes to read and you’ll learn:

• The UPLIFT framework: Six essential elements for designing upgrade paths that convert without compromising user experience.

• The psychology behind effective upgrade prompts: Why timing, context, and framing matter more than feature limitations alone.

• The metrics you should use to measure upgrade success: Beyond conversion rates to the indicators that predict sustainable revenue growth.

Let’s go!

TOGETHER WITH INFLECTION.IO

Downloadable File: Customer Lifecycle Journey of Databricks

Databricks is on fire 🔥 

ARR surpassing $3B and still growing 60%+ YoY growth, they've scaled to over 8,000 employees and just raised a $10B round.

We wanted to learn their secrets, so spent over 20 hours doing a lifecycle marketing review. We’ve prepared a Figma file with the complete customer lifecycle journey of Databricks and we are giving it away for free!

Please support our sponsors!

GEEK LINKS

GEEK OUT

How to Design High-Converting Upgrade Paths in Self-Serve PLG

In PLG, the product experience drives conversion from free to paid.

Unlike traditional sales-led (or hybrid PLS) models, pure PLG relies exclusively on users self-serving their upgrades, making the design of upgrade paths absolutely critical.

The user experience must clearly communicate value, prompt at the right time, and make upgrading a low friction exercise.

Yet it’s easy for B2B SaaS companies to get this wrong.

They either bombard users with generic upgrade prompts that feel like nagging, or they bury upgrade options so deep that users never discover the premium features that could solve their problems.

The result? Poor conversion rates and frustrated users.

Theres a pretty simple solution to this though. It’s all centred around designing upgrade paths that effectively balance business goals with user experience.

In this post, I'll share a useful framework that provides a systematic approach to designing upgrade paths that convert without compromising user satisfaction.

Here's what we'll cover:

1. Why upgrade paths matter (and the cost of getting them wrong)

2. The UPLIFT Framework for designing effective upgrade paths

3. The UX patterns that actually drive conversions

4. Measuring success: the metrics that matter

Let's dive in.

Why Upgrade Paths Matter (and the Cost of Getting Them Wrong)

The economics of PLG are brutally simple: acquiring users at scale through a free offering is only viable if you can convert a sufficient percentage to paid plans.

According to benchmarks, self-serve freemium products convert roughly 3–5% of free users to paid on average, with the best performers reaching 6–8%.

For time-limited free trials, good conversion rates hover around 8–12%, with exceptional products hitting 15–25%.

These seemingly small percentages have enormous implications.

Improving your conversion rate from 3% to 6% effectively doubles your revenue without acquiring a single additional user. This is why optimising upgrade paths is often the highest-leverage growth initiative for a PLG business.

When companies get upgrade paths wrong, they typically fall into one of two traps:

Too Pushy: Bombarding users with intrusive upgrade prompts before they've experienced value. This approach kills activation rates, increases churn, and damages brand perception.

Too Bashful: Being so afraid of appearing "salesy" that upgrade options are nearly invisible. I've seen companies hide their upgrade prompts in obscure parts of the settings menu, resulting in users who want to upgrade but can't figure out how.

The cost of poor upgrade path design extends beyond conversion rates. It impacts:

• User trust: Aggressive or deceptive upgrade tactics erode trust

• Product perception: Poorly timed prompts make even great products feel like bait and switch

• Revenue predictability: Suboptimal upgrade paths lead to spiky, unpredictable conversion patterns

Upgrade paths done right feel less like sales pitches and more like natural extensions of the user journey. The upgrade prompts arrive exactly when users are primed to appreciate them, making the decision to pay feel like a logical next step rather than an unwelcome interruption.

Let's explore how to build upgrade paths that achieve this balance.

The UPLIFT Framework for Designing Effective Upgrade Paths

I've distilled the elements of effective upgrade paths into a framework I call UPLIFT:

• Understand your users/teams’ journey and value moments

• Package your offers strategically along that journey

• Limit selectively to create natural upgrade triggers

• Integrate upgrade flows seamlessly into the product

• Frame upgrades as solutions, not transactions

• Test, measure, and optimise continuously

Let's break down each component:

Understand

Before designing any upgrade path, you need to deeply understand your users/teams’ journey: how they adopt your product, where they find value, and what problems they're ultimately trying to solve.

The key questions to answer are:

• What are the specific aha moments when users first experience value?

• What are the common growth trajectories as users become more advanced?

• What features or capabilities become important at different stages?

• What usage patterns indicate a user/team is ready for more?

At Snyk, we had a generous free plan that met the needs for the vast majority of individual users, and that was intentional. 

A big part of the strategy was to build a massive free user base, and we weren’t trying to monetise individual devs.

We knew that that individual developers getting value from Snyk for free would be more likely to become paying customers when their needs expanded, such as when they wanted to use Snyk within a larger team or transition from a personal to a business use-case.

We also allowed free usage for teams working on open source projects. It was common for devs who started using Snyk on their open source projects to later introduce it at the companies they worked at.

And we’d get a big boost to visibility within the dev community when Snyk was used on major open source projects. Features like automatic pull requests would make it easy for other devs to discover Snyk, so there was a nice acquisition growth loop there too.

Once of our core value metrics was the number of tests being run.

We intentionally avoided gating the number of developers in free accounts because we didn’t to constrain some important intra-company acquisition loops we had in place.

So we aimed to get more devs in teams to sign up. And we knew that more devs joining and securing more projects would lead to more tests being run.

So we used the number of tests as a gate between the free and paid plans.

The free plan had test limits, and if you upgraded to paid plan you’d get unlimited tests.

We didn’t actually enforce test limits in the app because Snyk is typically used in automated DevOps pipelines, and enforcing test limits would potentially break these pipelines, blocking new product releases for our customers.

This was counter to our dev-first approach.

If you’re in this situation, graceful degradation of service is always better than blocking access to value and interrupting core user/team workflows. Another great example here is Cursor moving you to slow requests once you deplete all of your fast requests.

Action step: Map your user journey and identify the key value moments. Interview users who recently upgraded to understand what triggered their decision.

Package

With a clear understanding of the user journey, you can strategically design your packaging to align with natural progression points. Each tier should solve specific problems that emerge as users grow in sophistication or scale.

Effective PLG packaging follows these principles:

• The free tier delivers genuine value (solves a real problem)

• Each paid tier unlocks capabilities that address specific evolving needs

• Tier jumps feel like natural progressions, not arbitrary upsells

• The value delta between tiers justifies the price increase (perceived value outweighs the cost)

I’ll use Slack as an example here:

Each tier addresses specific needs that emerge as teams grow:

• Pro addresses the needs of teams outgrowing basic usage

• Business+ addresses security and compliance needs of larger organizations

• Enterprise Grid addresses the complex needs of large enterprises with multiple departments

And the jumps between tiers are natural progressions that align perfectly with natural growth points for organisations:

• Free → Pro: When message history becomes critical and teams need more integrations

• Pro → Business+: When security, compliance, and guaranteed uptime become essential

• Business+ → Enterprise Grid: When an organization needs multiple workspaces and enterprise-grade administration

Action step: Review your current pricing tiers. Do they map to distinct stages in the user journey, or do they feel arbitrary? Realign them if necessary.

Limit

Strategic limitations create natural upgrade triggers when users outgrow their current tier. The art is implementing limits that allow sufficient value before triggering an upgrade conversation.

Three types of limits are particularly effective:

1. Usage limits: Caps on volume metrics like storage, users, or projects

2. Feature gates: Advanced capabilities reserved for higher tiers

3. Time restrictions: Duration limits (like Zoom's 40-minute cap on group meetings)

The most successful limits share these characteristics:

• They kick in after users have experienced significant value

• They're directly tied to increased value (not arbitrary restrictions)

• They're transparent and predictable (no surprises)

• They create a "positive friction" moment where upgrading feels like the natural solution

Zoom's 40-minute limit on free group meetings demonstrates this perfectly: it's long enough to handle most casual meetings, but professional teams who need longer sessions quickly recognise the value of upgrading. The limit is also transparent (Zoom warns users as they approach it) and directly tied to increased value (uninterrupted meetings).

Action step: Review your current limits. Are they triggering upgrade conversations at the right moments, or are they hitting too early (before value is established) or too late (after users find workarounds)?

Integrate

The actual upgrade flow should feel seamlessly integrated into the product experience. This covers everything from how upgrade opportunities are surfaced to the mechanics of completing the purchase.

Effective integration includes:

• Contextual entry points that appear when relevant (not random pop-ups)

• Clear upgrade paths that take minimal clicks

• Smooth transitions between free and paid experiences

• Persistent but unobtrusive reminders of upgrade options

If I want to invite external collaborators to a Miro board, I’m prompted to upgrade to the Business Plan:

But note that contextual entry points doesn’t always equate to just-in-time.

Dropbox integrates upgrade opportunities into their interface with a persistent but unobtrusive banner about storage limits, complemented by an "Start free trial" button in the top menu. In the core file storage interface, storage limits are contextually relevant.

Their approach ensures users always have a path to upgrade without disrupting their workflow.

Action step: Map all the potential upgrade entry points in your product. Are they appearing in relevant contexts? How many clicks does it take to complete an upgrade?

Frame

The way you frame upgrade messages dramatically impacts conversion. Effective framing positions the upgrade as a solution to a problem the user is experiencing, not as a transaction.

Principles of effective framing include:

• Focus on the capabilities and use cases you can unlock

• Use positive language that emphasises gains rather than restrictions

• Connect directly to the user's current context or pain point

• Create a sense of progress ("Take your workflow to the next level")

Semrush frames their data limitations positively. When users try to access historical data beyond their current plan, they display "Start analyzing your competitors with Semrush .Trends + Pro" transforming a limitation into a competitive intelligence opportunity that resonates with their B2B marketing audience.

Action step: Audit your upgrade messaging. Does it focus on value unlocks? Does it connect to specific user needs or contexts?

Test & Optimise

Finally, effective upgrade paths require continuous testing and optimisation based on data and user feedback.

Key areas to test include:

• Timing of upgrade prompts

• Language and framing of messages

• Visual design and prominence of calls-to-action

• Placement of upgrade entry points

• Specific features or limits that trigger upgrades

The most successful PLG companies treat their upgrade paths as living systems that evolve with user behaviour and feedback. They monitor key metrics (which we'll cover later) and systematically test improvements.

Action step: Identify your top 2-3 upgrade paths and design simple A/B tests to improve each one. If your traffic volume is too low for statistically significant A/B tests, consider these alternatives:

1. Sequential testing: Test one change at a time for 2-4 week periods and compare results to your baseline metrics. While not as clean as a true A/B test, you’ll still yield insights.

2. Qualitative testing: Run moderated usability sessions with 5-8 users watching how they interact with your upgrade flows. Jakob Nielsen's research shows that testing with just 5 users can uncover ~85% of usability issues.

3. Fake door testing: For new upgrade features, create the entry point (button/link) but show a "coming soon" message when clicked, measuring interest through click rates.

4. Customer interviews: Talk directly to users who have both converted and those who haven't to understand their decision process.

5. Heat mapping: Use tools like PostHog and Fullstory to see where users are focusing, clicking, or abandoning on upgrade-related pages.

Even with low traffic, consistent measurement and incremental improvements compound over time.

The UPLIFT framework provides a systematic approach to upgrade path design that balances business goals with user experience.

The UX Patterns That Actually Drive Conversions

With your upgrade strategy and mechanisms in place, the next crucial element is the user experience of the upgrade flow itself.

How you present upgrade opportunities dramatically impacts conversion rates.

Here are the most effective UX patterns I’ve seen:

Contextual Prompts at Moments of Need

What it is: Presenting upgrade options precisely when a user attempts to use a premium feature or hits a usage limit.

Why it works: These prompts arrive when users are actively trying to do something beyond their current plan, making the upgrade immediately relevant.

Example: Open Slack and search for an older message. You’ll see a thoughtfully crafted prompt: "Messages and files on the free version of Slack are hidden after 90 days. Upgrade to a paid plan to see more of your message and file history in search results." It’s not pushy or annoying, and it appears precisely in the moment of need.

Implementation tips:

• Identify all points where users might hit limits or attempt premium actions

• Design consistent but context-aware prompts for each

• Make the connection between the user's current action and the upgrade explicit

• Provide a direct path to upgrade without unnecessary steps

Persistent But Unobtrusive Indicators

What it is: Subtle, always-visible reminders of current plan limitations or upgrade options.

Why it works: These maintain awareness without interrupting workflow, ensuring users know how to upgrade when they're ready.

Example: Trello displays a persistent banner in their sidebar showing premium plan benefits but also cleverly shows a persistent card in the boards list that counts remaining free boards and provides a quick path to upgrade to unlimited boards.

Implementation tips:

• Place indicators outside the primary workflow areas

• Include relevant metrics (e.g., ‘3/5 projects used’)

• Make indicators dismissible but ensure the path to upgrade remains accessible

• Periodically refresh the design to avoid ‘banner blindness’

Preview and Tease Premium Features

What it is: Making premium features visible but clearly marked, sometimes with limited functionality to demonstrate value.

Why it works: Users can't want what they don't know exists. This approach creates awareness and curiosity about premium capabilities.

Example: Loveable.dev projects are public by default. It’s a simple toggle to make them private, but doing so will take you into the flow to upgrade to the starter plan.

Implementation tips:

• Add visual indicators (lock icons, ‘Premium’ badges) to gated features

• Provide informative previews or demos when users interact with gated elements

• Frame the premium feature in terms of the problem it solves

• Consider offering limited "trial" access to specific premium features

Frictionless Upgrade Flows

What it is: Streamlined, in-app upgrade processes that minimize steps and friction.

Why it works: Every additional click or page load creates an opportunity for users to abandon the upgrade process.

Example: Navattic implemented a low friction in-app upgrade flow that allowed free users to explore plans and complete purchases without leaving the product. After implementing this streamlined flow, they saw their free-to-paid conversion rate increase from 1-2% to approximately 5%.

Implementation tips:

• Minimise the steps between decision and completion (ideally 3 clicks or fewer)

• Keep the upgrade flow within the app when possible

• Pre-fill any information you already have

• Show clear plan comparisons at the point of decision

• Implement secure, reliable payment processing

Smart Email Sequences

What it is: Targeted emails triggered by specific user behaviours or milestones.

Why it works: Not all upgrades happen in-app. Email sequences catch users when they're outside the product but might be receptive to upgrading.

Real-world example: During free trials, Reflect sends a sequence that starts with helpful onboarding, transitions to highlighting specific valuable features, and concludes with "trial ending" reminders. The messaging evolves from educational to more sales-oriented (though not overtly pushy) as the trial progresses.

Implementation tips:

• Align email triggers with in-app behaviour (usage milestones, feature exploration)

• Progress from helpful/educational to more direct as engagement increases

• Personalise emails based on the specific features the user has explored

• Include direct deep links to the upgrade flow

• A/B test subject lines and messaging to optimise open and conversion rates

Recommended extra reading:

Multi-touchpoint Approach

The most effective upgrade experiences use multiple UX patterns in concert. For example:

1. A user approaches their usage limit → receives an in-app notification

2. They dismiss the notification → see a persistent indicator in their dashboard

3. They explore a premium feature → get a contextual preview with benefits explanation

4. They leave without upgrading → receive a targeted email the next day

5. They return to the product → see a personalised banner based on their previous exploration

This layered approach ensures upgrade opportunities are visible without being overwhelming, and it accommodates different user decision-making styles.

Measuring Success: The Metrics That Matter

To optimise your upgrade paths effectively, you need to measure the right metrics. Here are the key indicators to track, along with benchmarks and optimisation strategies:

Primary Metrics

1. Free-to-Paid Conversion Rate

What it measures: The percentage of free users who convert to paid plans within a specific timeframe.

Why it matters: Small improvements here can dramatically impact revenue - a 1% increase in conversion rate can translate to millions in additional ARR for companies with large free user bases.

Industry benchmarks:

• Self-serve freemium: 3-5% is good, 6-8% is excellent

• Free trials: 8-12% is good, 15-25% is excellent

How to improve it:

• Implement the UPLIFT framework systematically

• Test different upgrade triggers and messages

• Reduce friction in the upgrade flow

• Enhance the perceived value gap between free and paid

2. Time to Conversion

What it measures: How long it takes for users to upgrade after initial sign-up.

Why it matters: While faster conversion might seem better, extremely quick conversions can indicate your free tier is too limited. Appropriate friction and time to value can enhance learning and habit formation. Conversely, very long conversion times may suggest weak upgrade incentives.

How to improve it:

• Identify the natural "graduation points" in your user journey

• Align upgrade prompts with these moments

• A/B test trigger timing to find the optimal window

3. Upgrade Path Effectiveness

What it measures: Which paths and triggers lead to the most conversions.

What to track:

• Conversion rates by upgrade entry point (e.g., usage limit hit, feature gate, email)

• Click-through rates on upgrade prompts

• Completion rate of upgrade flows (started vs. completed)

How to improve it:

• Double down on your highest-converting paths

• Redesign or remove low-performing triggers

• Reduce steps in paths with high abandonment rates

Secondary Metrics

4. Post-Upgrade Retention / Churn

What it measures: How long users stay subscribed after upgrading.

Why it matters: High conversion followed by rapid cancellation indicates upgrade buyers' remorse usually because realised value does not align with expectation.

How to improve it:

• Create thoughtful post-upgrade onboarding

• Ensure users quickly access the premium features they paid for

• Monitor usage of premium features after upgrade

5. Premium Feature Adoption

What it measures: Whether users are actually using the premium features they paid to access.

Why it matters: Low premium feature usage after upgrade predicts churn and indicates misalignment between your upgrade messaging and actual value.

How to improve it:

• Guide users to premium features immediately after upgrade

• Send targeted emails highlighting premium features they haven't tried

• Consider redesigning underused premium features

6. Expansion Revenue Percentage

What it measures: The proportion of new revenue coming from existing users upgrading to higher tiers (rather than new user acquisition).

Industry benchmarks: In mature PLG companies, 30-40% of new revenue often comes from expansions.

How to improve it:

• Design clear upgrade paths between paid tiers, not just from free to paid

• Apply the same UPLIFT principles to paid tier transitions

• Create usage milestones that trigger higher-tier conversations

Build Upgrade Paths, Not Paywalls

The best PLG companies think in terms of upgrade paths, not paywalls.

The difference is subtle but profound.

A paywall blocks users until they pay. An upgrade path guides users along a journey where paying feels like a natural progression - the logical next step as they derive more value from your product.

This distinction matters because sustainable PLG growth is centred on aligning payment with value delivered.

An exchange of value.

When users upgrade because they genuinely need and want the additional capabilities, they stay longer, use the product more, and become advocates who bring in more users.

The UPLIFT framework provides a systematic approach to building these value-aligned upgrade paths:

• Understand your users/teams' journey and key value moments

• Package your offers to align with natural progression points

• Limit strategically to create meaningful upgrade triggers

• Integrate upgrade flows seamlessly into the product

• Frame upgrades as solutions, not transactions

• Test & optimise continuously based on data

As you implement this framework, remember that the goal isn't to maximise short-term conversion.

Instead, think about how to create a sustainable growth engine where free users experience genuine value, some portion convert when the time is right, and paid users receive even greater value that justifies their investment.

An important lens to use is that free users are potential paying users at an earlier stage of their journey.

Some will remain free users forever, and that's fine - they contribute to the network effect and may bring in others who do upgrade. Some will upgrade when their needs evolve.

And when the upgrade experience is thoughtfully designed, those conversions happen naturally, with users upgrading because they want to, not because they're forced to.

So, what's your next step? Start by mapping your user journey and identifying the natural upgrade moments that already exist. Then, apply the UPLIFT framework to design upgrade paths that feel less like sales pitches and more like helpful solutions appearing at exactly the right moment. 

Your users - and your conversion rates - will thank you.

THAT’S A WRAP

Before you go, here are 3 ways I can help:

Take the FREE Learning Velocity Index assessment - Discover how your team's ability to learn and leverage learnings stacks up in the product-led world. Takes 2 minutes and you get free advice.

Book a free 1:1 consultation call with me - I keep a handful of slots open each week for founders and product growth leaders to explore working together and get some free advice along the way. Book a call.

Sponsor this newsletter - Reach over 7600 founders, leaders and operators working in product and growth at some of the world’s best tech companies including Paypal, Adobe, Canva, Miro, Amplitude, Google, Meta, Tailscale, Twilio and Salesforce.

That’s all for today,

If there are any product, growth or leadership topics that you’d like me to write about, just hit reply to this email or leave a comment and let me know!

And if you enjoyed this post, consider upgrading to a VIG Membership to get the full Product-Led Geek experience and access to every post in the archive including all guides.

Until next time!

— Ben

PS: Thanks again to our sponsor: Inflection.io