Hey folks! 👋

Here’s what you’ll find in today’s edition of the Product-Led Geek:

• Learn why your self-serve motion might be underperforming compared to your enterprise sales success and how to diagnose the root causes.

• Master the three critical areas where product-led motions often fail: customer targeting, journey optimisation, and pricing alignment.

• Discover how to transform your self-serve weakness into strength by embedding successful enterprise success patterns into your product experience.

Total reading time: 7 minutes

Let’s go!

TOGETHER WITH DOVETAIL

From AI analysis to insights where you work, Dovetail 3.0 is more than just an upgrade for research—it’s a whole new way to understand customers.

Get the next generation of customer insights. Dovetail’s automated analysis does the heavy lifting across calls, documents, survey responses, and more.

Please support our sponsors!

GEEK OUT

3 Reasons Your Self-Serve Motion Isn't Matching Your Sales Success (and how to fix it)

"Our sales team is crushing it with enterprise deals, but our self-serve motion isn't delivering."

I’ve heard this from founders and PLG leaders more than a few times in recent weeks.

This disconnect between sales-led and product-led success is common as companies scale.

Assuming you have strong product-market fit (and your sales team isn't over-promising), there are three common root causes:

1. Your product-led motion isn't attracting the right customers.

2. Your self-serve experience isn't as effective as your sales motion in converting awareness to revenue.

3. Your pricing and packaging don't align with the expectations of lower-end market customers.

Let's explore these and I'll share my framework for diagnosing and fixing this disconnect.

Attracting the Wrong Customers

This pattern is common:

Sales teams target and close deals with ideal customers who understand the problem space and are ready to invest in a solution.

Self-serve channels attract a broader, often less qualified audience - including users casually exploring or not experiencing enough pain to justify a purchase.

You see healthy top-of-funnel metrics, but poor conversion.

Support teams get stretched thin handling questions from unsuitable users.

Optimising the self-serve experience becomes difficult due to a fragmented user base.

Take a step back to understand your enterprise success stories:

• What problems drove them to seek a solution?

• What trigger events prompted action?

• How did they evaluate and choose your product?

With these insights, you can reshape your self-serve acquisition strategy to attract users resembling your successful enterprise customers - at an earlier stage.

This alignment is fundamental to Product-Led Sales, where you'll identify and nurture potential enterprise customers based on their product usage patterns.

The Journey Gap

Your sales team guides prospects to value.

They know which features to highlight, which use cases resonate, and how to address objections.

Self-serve users must navigate this journey alone.

You can see these differences in one or more of these ways:

1. Value Discovery:

   • Sales-led: Reps identify and articulate relevant use cases.

   • Self-serve: Users must find the value themselves.

2. Implementation Support:

   • Sales-led: White-glove onboarding and setup

   • Self-serve: DIY with documentation and (potentially) community support

3. Monetisation Awareness:

   • Sales-led: Sellers build a compelling narrative

   • Self-serve: Users rely on in-app prompts, triggers and nudges

This journey gap is about the difference between guided and self-directed discovery.

We can't (and shouldn't) try to replicate the high-touch sales experience exactly, but we can strategically embed sales' most effective tactics into our product experience.

The key is identifying the sales-led journey aspects that create the most value, then translating those into scalable product features, automated workflows, and contextual guidance that help users succeed independently.

And - highly recommended - using product usage data to determine when and how to introduce human touch points.

Pricing and Packaging Misalignment

Your enterprise pricing might be well-tuned (and has the benefit of conversation and negotiation) while your self-serve plans don't quite hit the spot.

This is an often neglected aspect.

Even with obvious signs, companies are hesitant to change their pricing and packaging.

Here are the most common pricing mistakes I see companies make:

1. Misaligned Value-Price Ratio

   • Enterprise tiers reflect value through negotiation.

   • Self-serve tiers priced based on competition or gut feel.

   • Result: Pricing doesn't match perceived value at each level.

2. Free Plan Imbalance

   • Giving away too much (hurting conversion), or

   • Restricting too much (preventing meaningful evaluation).

   • Sweet spot: Enough value to demonstrate value, clear path to paid.

3. Poor Usage Limits

   • Usage caps that cut off right when teams see value, before habit formation.

   • Arbitrary limits not tied to customer success metrics.

   • Missing opportunities for natural expansion triggers.

4. Ineffective Value Metrics

   • Charging based on metrics customers don't care about.

   • Complex pricing structures that create friction.

   • Metrics that don't scale with customer value.

5. Feature Segmentation Issues

   • Too big a gap between free and paid features.

   • Critical features in wrong tiers.

   • Lack of clear upgrade motivation between tiers.

The key is finding the right balance - pricing that reflects value, encourages adoption, and creates expansion opportunities as customers grow.

Diagnosing Your Situation

Before finding solutions, identify the problem.

Investigate these three potential root causes in order:

1. Wrong Customers - Are you attracting the right users?

2. Journey Gap - Is your self-serve experience effectively guiding users?

3. Pricing Misalignment - Does your pricing and packaging structure make sense?

This order is critical because fixing pricing won't help if you're attracting the wrong customers, and optimising the journey is futile if they're not a good fit.

To diagnose, follow these steps:

1. Analyse Customer Fit

First, determine if you're attracting the right customers by analysing these key areas:

Acquisition Quality Metrics:

• Sign-up rates by channel

• Activation rates by channel

• Initial feature adoption patterns

• Early support ticket themes

Customer Comparison Analysis:

• Self-serve vs. enterprise user/team profile vs ICP

• Primary use cases and pain points

• Purchase triggers and evaluation criteria

Red Flags:

• High bounce rates from key features

• Misaligned feature usage patterns

• Support tickets indicating expectation mismatch

• Low activation rates despite healthy traffic

Note: Aim for your self-serve and sales-led motions to cater to the same ICP (though sometimes at different scales)

2. Evaluate the Customer Journey

If your customer profile is sound, examine the journey gap:

Journey Mapping:

• Document successful enterprise onboarding paths

• Map self-serve user/team activation flows

• Identify key drop-off points

Critical Touchpoints Analysis:

• Feature discovery patterns

• Onboarding success rates

• Key activation milestones

• Usage depth over time

Red Flags:

• High drop-off at specific journey points

• Poor feature discovery rates

• Shallow usage patterns

This helps pinpoint where your self-serve experience might lack critical elements that sales provides.

3. Assess Pricing and Packaging Misalignment

Only after addressing the above, evaluate pricing structure:

Pricing Analysis:

• Value perception surveys

• Usage patterns vs. pricing tiers

• Upgrade/downgrade triggers

• Feature adoption across tiers

Package Evaluation:

• Free-to-paid conversion rates

• Feature utilisation by tier

• Natural expansion triggers

• Competitive positioning

Red Flags:

• Frequent downgrade requests

• Low expansion rates

• Pricing objections in customer feedback

Find Your Forcing Function

The disconnect between sales-led and product-led success should be viewed as an opportunity to build a more cohesive growth engine.

The key thing to takeaway is:

Your enterprise success contains the DNA for your self-serve success.

But you can't just copy-paste the enterprise playbook.

Your task is to transpose those winning elements into a scalable self-serve motion:

1. Align Your Acquisition Strategy

   • Target self-serve prospects who mirror your successful enterprise customers' early stages.

   • Focus messaging on the common core pain points driving success in larger deals.

2. Decode Your Enterprise Success

   • Map out why enterprise customers succeed with your product.

   • Identify which success factors are universal vs. enterprise-specific.

   • Document the key moments that drive long-term adoption.

3. Embed Success Patterns into Self-Serve

   • Translate high-touch sales interactions into automated guidance.

   • Build product flows that mirror your most effective sales narratives.

   • Create self-service versions of your best implementation practices.

4. Design for Growth

   • Build clear upgrade paths from self-serve to enterprise.

   • Identify and nurture accounts with enterprise potential.

   • Create natural expansion moments that align with customer success.

5. Amplify with Product-Led Sales

   • Use product usage data to identify expansion opportunities.

   • Create clear signals for sales team intervention.

   • Build automated workflows for hybrid buying journeys.

Remember: Today's self-serve customers are tomorrow's enterprise buyers.

By bridging this gap, you're building a foundation for sustainable growth across both motions.

Product-led and sales-led growth are complementary forces that, when aligned, create a powerful flywheel for sustained growth.

This is where Product-Led Sales becomes transformative.

It’s a forcing function for synergy and improved performance in both motions.

It demands that you think holistically about how self-serve and sales-led approaches complement each other.

When building a Product-Led Sales motion, you're pushed to:

• Understand how product usage signals translate to sales opportunities.

• Create seamless handoffs between self-serve and sales-assisted journeys.

• Design pricing and packaging that supports both paths.

• Align your organisation around customer success, regardless of acquisition channel.

Product-Led Sales creates a unified go-to-market approach that makes the most of both strategies while putting the customer journey at the centre.

If you’re hungry for more on this topic, see below:

GEEK OF THE WEEK

What's the most impactful piece of user feedback you've ever received?

THAT’S A WRAP

Before you go, here are 3 ways I can help:

Take the FREE Learning Velocity Index assessment - Discover how your team's ability to learn and leverage learnings stacks up in the product-led world. Takes 2 minutes and you get free advice.

Book a free 1:1 consultation call with me - I keep a handful of slots open each week for founders and product growth leaders to explore working together and get some free advice along the way. Book a call.

Sponsor this newsletter - Reach over 7800 founders, leaders and operators working in product and growth at some of the world’s best tech companies including Paypal, Adobe, Canva, Miro, Amplitude, Google, Meta, Tailscale, Twilio and Salesforce.

That’s all for today,

If there are any product, growth or leadership topics that you’d like me to write about, just hit reply to this email or leave a comment and let me know!

And if you enjoyed this post, consider upgrading to a VIG Membership to get the full Product-Led Geek experience and access to every post in the archive including all guides.

Until next time!

— Ben

PS: Thanks again to our sponsor: Dovetail